How to value a company for an EOT sale
The trustees of an Employee Ownership Trust (EOT) must take reasonable steps to pay no more than market value for the shares. In practice that means a written valuation, prepared for the purpose by someone competent, using methods that fit the business. The price you agree should be supported by it.
Why the valuation matters more now
Since 30 October 2024, trustees have an express duty to take reasonable steps on market value. A valuation also supports your own tax position and the HMRC clearance. See HMRC clearance for an EOT sale.
A price that cannot be defended exposes the sale to challenge. It also exposes the trustees, who must show that they did not overpay.
What market value means here
Market value is the price the shares would reach in an open market between a willing buyer and a willing seller. A trade buyer may pay more because of benefits only they can realise. The EOT trustees are buying for the employees, so the price should reflect the company as it is, not the strategic premium a specific buyer might pay. The two figures can differ.
Common methods
Which method fits depends on the company.
- Earnings-based. A multiple of maintainable profit, adjusted for the owner's pay and one-off items. Suited to stable trading businesses.
- Discounted cash flow. The present value of expected future cash. Suited where growth or investment changes the profile.
- Recurring revenue. A multiple of regular, contracted income. Suited to subscription or fee-based models.
- Net assets. The value of the balance sheet. Suited to asset-heavy businesses or as a floor.
A valuer will often test the answer with more than one method and explain the choice. We do not state a multiple here, because the right figure depends on the sector, the size and the quality of earnings.
A worked example
These figures are hypothetical. A company earns normalised profit of £1m after paying the owner a market salary. The valuer, after considering the business, applies a multiple that gives an equity value of £4m. The owner thinks it is worth £5m because a trade buyer once expressed interest.
The trustees cannot simply agree £5m. They need a reason for paying above the independent valuation, and the rules require them to take reasonable steps not to exceed market value. The practical answer is to price at or around the valuation, and to document the reasoning. The owner can then decide if £4m paid to a trust is better or worse than a trade offer after tax and risk. See EOT vs trade sale vs management buyout.
What the trustees need to keep
- The valuation report and the instructions to the valuer
- The key assumptions and any sensitivity analysis
- Board minutes showing they considered and challenged the valuation
- Evidence on the funding, so the price is affordable
- A note of any difference between the agreed price and the valuation, with reasons
Adjusting the numbers
Before any method is applied, the profit figure usually needs adjusting. Typical adjustments include:
- Setting the owner's pay at a market level for the role
- Removing one-off costs or income
- Taking out personal expenses run through the company
- Allowing for the cost of replacing the owner's work
- Checking that the business can keep trading without the owner
These adjustments often move the valuation more than the choice of method does. Agree them early and document each one.
Pitfalls
- Using the owner's number. A figure from the seller, with no independent check, will not satisfy the test.
- Ignoring affordability. A valuation the company cannot fund is not a workable price. See how an EOT sale is funded through deferred consideration.
- Out-of-date numbers. Trading can change between the valuation date and completion. Update the valuation if it does.
- Inconsistent forecasts. The valuation, the funding model and the clearance application should rest on the same numbers.
- Weak independence. The valuer should be free of conflicts, and the trustees should be independent of the seller.
Our role
We do not replace the valuer. We help you brief them, review how the valuation connects to the tax and funding, and make sure the evidence stands up. Our page on EOT valuation and funding describes the support in more detail.
Thinking about selling to an Employee Ownership Trust? Book a call with our team.
FAQs
Must the EOT pay market value?
The trustees must take reasonable steps to make sure they pay no more than market value. This has applied since 30 October 2024.
Can I use the valuation from a previous share issue?
Possibly as a reference point, but an EOT sale needs a current valuation prepared for the purpose.
Do I need an independent valuer?
It is strongly advisable. An independent valuation gives the trustees and HMRC a reasoned basis for the price.
Is the EOT price lower than a trade sale price?
It can be, because a trade buyer may pay for synergies and the EOT trustees are limited to market value.
Talk to our team. We respond the same working day.