EOT clawback and disqualifying events
A sale to an Employee Ownership Trust (EOT) does not end the tax rules at completion. If a disqualifying event occurs afterwards, a charge can arise on the trustees. It can also arise on you, the seller, if the event happens within the clawback period.
What is a disqualifying event
A disqualifying event is an event after the sale which means the conditions for the relief are no longer met. Examples include:
- The trust ceasing to hold a controlling interest in the company
- The company ceasing to be a trading company, or the holding company of a trading group
- A breach of the all-employee benefit requirement
- The limited participation requirement no longer being met
The exact scope of the rules is detailed, so we review the precise facts when we advise. See the qualifying conditions for the underlying tests.
Who is charged
The trustees can be charged where a disqualifying event occurs. The charge reflects the relief that was given on the sale.
The seller can also be charged if the event falls within the clawback period. Since 30 October 2024, that period runs to the end of the fourth tax year after the tax year of disposal. The vendor's return also needs extra information.
This is the reason owners should not treat the sale as the end of the matter. For several years you have a continuing interest in the company staying within the rules.
A worked example
This is hypothetical. A company is sold to an EOT in the 2026/27 tax year. The clawback period runs to the end of the fourth tax year after that, which is the end of 2030/31. In 2029 the trustees sell a part of the shares to an outside investor and the trust falls below a controlling interest. That is a disqualifying event inside the clawback period.
The trustees may face a charge. You may face a charge too. The outcome depends on the facts and the legislation, and a charge of this kind can be large, because it relates to the relief given on the original sale.
Common causes in practice
- A later share sale or fundraising that dilutes the trust below control
- A change in the business that makes it non-trading
- A bonus or benefit plan that favours some employees over others
- A change in the workforce that breaks the limited participation test
- A change in the trustee board that gives former owners control
Protecting yourself
- Structure it carefully at the start. Many problems start with weak design. Our EOT sale tax advice covers this.
- Write protections into the sale documents. Covenants and information rights help you see problems early.
- Agree a governance routine. Review the conditions each year, with a short written check.
- Take advice before any change. A new investor, acquisition or reorganisation needs checking against the conditions first.
- Keep the records. Trustee minutes, valuations and employee data should be filed and kept up to date.
Tax-free bonuses and other benefits
A bonus plan is a common area for error. Payments must be on the same terms for eligible employees. See EOT tax-free bonus of £3,600 for how the bonus works.
Trustee conduct
The trustee rules that came in from 30 October 2024 add to the risk of a breach if they are ignored. The trustees must be UK resident, and former owners and connected persons must not control the board. See EOT trustee rules after the 2024 Budget.
An annual check
We suggest a short annual check, completed by the trustees and the company, which covers:
- Who holds the shares, and whether the trust still has more than 50% of each of the control measures
- Whether the company is still trading, and what any subsidiaries do
- Whether any bonus or benefit has been paid, and on what terms
- The make-up of the workforce, including any change in family members employed
- The make-up of the trustee board, and any new connections
- Whether anything is planned that would change the above
A one-page record, dated and signed, is useful evidence if HMRC asks questions later.
What to do if an event is looming
Speak to us before you act. A planned transaction can sometimes be restructured to avoid a breach. Once a disqualifying event has happened, the options are narrower.
Thinking about selling to an Employee Ownership Trust? Book a call with our team.
FAQs
What is a disqualifying event?
It is an event after the sale that means the EOT conditions are no longer met, such as the trust losing control or a breach of the all-employee benefit requirement.
How long is the clawback period for the seller?
It runs to the end of the fourth tax year after the tax year of disposal.
Who pays the charge?
The charge can fall on the trustees. It can also fall on the seller if the event occurs within the clawback period.
Can we reduce the risk?
Yes. Careful structuring, clear governance and regular monitoring all help, and we agree a compliance routine with you.
Talk to our team. We respond the same working day.